Monday, February 07, 2005

UNLV accused of limiting free speech




Here is another case of campus PC bullshit. Though the Sailor will admit he thought hell had frozen over when the Red Sox won the World Series and now the ACLU comes to the defense of a conservative professor. Go figure. - Sailor


Lecture causes dispute


UNLV accused of limiting free speech

By RICHARD LAKE REVIEW-JOURNAL

A UNLV professor under fire for comments he made about homosexuals during a class lecture last year demanded Friday that the university stop threatening to punish him.


"I have done absolutely nothing wrong," said the professor, Hans Hoppe, a conservative libertarian economist with almost 20 years teaching experience at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas.


The American Civil Liberties Union of Nevada, on Hoppe's behalf, sent a letter to UNLV officials alleging that the university violated Hoppe's free speech rights and his right to academic freedom.


"The charge against professor Hoppe is totally specious and without merit," reads the letter from ACLU attorney Allen Lichtenstein.


He said they would sue the university if necessary, though they hope to avoid it.


UNLV officials would not comment on the case, saying they cannot talk publicly about personnel matters.
Hoppe, 55, a world-renowned economist, author and speaker, said he was giving a lecture to his money and banking class in March when the incident occurred.


The subject of the lecture was economic planning for the future. Hoppe said he gave several examples to the class of about 30 upper-level undergraduate students on groups who tend to plan for the future and groups who do not.


Very young and very old people, for example, tend not to plan for the future, he said. Couples with children tend to plan more than couples without.


As in all social sciences, he said, he was speaking in generalities.


Another example he gave the class was that homosexuals tend to plan less for the future than heterosexuals.
Reasons for the phenomenon include the fact that homosexuals tend not to have children, he said. They also tend to live riskier lifestyles than heterosexuals, Hoppe said.


He said there is a belief among some economists that one of the 20th century's most influential economists, John Maynard Keynes, was influenced in his beliefs by his homosexuality. Keynes espoused a "spend it now" philosophy to keep an economy strong, much as President Bush did after the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks.
Hoppe said the portion of the lecture on homosexuals lasted perhaps 90 seconds, while the entire lecture took up his 75-minute class.


There were no questions or any discussion from the students about the homosexual comments, he said.
"I have given lectures like this for 18 years," said Hoppe, a native of Germany who joined UNLV's faculty in 1986. "I have given this lecture all over the world and never had any complaints about it."


But within days of the lecture, he was notified by school officials that a student had lodged an informal complaint.

The student said Hoppe's comments offended him.


A series of formal hearings ensued.


Hoppe said that, at the request of university officials, he clarified in his next class that he was speaking in generalities only and did not mean to offend anyone.


As an example of what he meant, he offered this: Italians tend to eat more spaghetti than Germans, and Germans tend to eat more sauerkraut than Italians. It is not universally true, he said, but it is generally true.


The student then filed a formal complaint, Hoppe said, alleging that Hoppe did not take the complaint seriously.
He said university officials first said they would issue him a letter of reprimand and dock him a week's pay.


That option was rejected by Hoppe's dean and by the university provost, Hoppe said.


More hearings ensued, he said. In the end, the university gave him until Friday to accept its latest offer of punishment: It would issue him a letter of reprimand and he would give up his next pay increase.


Hoppe, a tenured full professor, contacted the ACLU on the recommendation of an attorney friend of his. Hoppe is now their client.


"I felt like I was the victim," he said, "not the student."


ACLU officials said the validity of Hoppe's economic theories does not matter. It is his right to espouse them in class.


"We don't subscribe to Hans' theories and certainly understand why some students find them offensive," said Gary Peck, the ACLU of Nevada's executive director.


"But academic freedom means nothing if it doesn't protect the right of professors to present scholarly ideas that are relevant to their curricula, even if they are controversial and rub people the wrong way."


Hoppe said he is dumbfounded by the university's response to the student's complaint. It is not his job, he said, to consider how a student might feel about economic theories.


"Our task is to teach what we consider to be right," he said. The offended student, he said, should have been told to "grow up."


Hoppe protested that university officials declined to speak to other students in the class to find out what actually happened and even rejected letters he solicited from a half-dozen students.


UNLV's general counsel, Richard Linstrom, would not talk about Hoppe's case, but said the university values free speech.


"The administration of UNLV is fully committed to academic freedom in all respects," he said. Linstrom said he was in a Board of Regents meeting most of Friday and had not seen the ACLU's letter.
Lichtenstein, the ACLU lawyer, said the university's response to Hoppe's situation might stifle free speech on the campus.


"If he can be silenced, that's going to create self-censorship among other faculty members who won't say anything controversial," he said. "Who's going to lose in all this? The students."


EasonGate




Please welcome EasonGate to the Sailor's blogroll. They are keeping on top of the Eason Jordan fiasco and doing a great job! Be sure to visit them and see what information they are posting. - Sailor


U.N. Oil-For-Food Program Chief Suspended


So the UN is going to discipline an employee? Old Kofi is going to lift diplomatic immunity if Volker finds grounds for criminal charges? I wonder if Annan will do that if it is his son that is implicated? What little credibility the UN has is on the line here. - Sailor



U.N. Oil-For-Food Program Chief Suspended
Feb 7, 2:41 PM (ET)
By EDITH M. LEDERER


UNITED NATIONS (AP) - Secretary-General Kofi Annan suspended the head of the U.N. oil-for-food program in Iraq and a senior official who dealt with contracts after an independent inquiry accused them of misconduct, a U.N. spokesman said Monday.

Benon Sevan, who was in charge of the $64 billion humanitarian program, and Joseph Stephanides, head of the U.N. Security Council Affairs Division, were informed Friday that they had been suspended with pay, spokesman Fred Eckhard said.

Sevan and Stephanides were told they would receive a letter "laying out the charges against them," which will allow them to defend themselves before U.N. disciplinary bodies, he said.

"Suspension is the beginning of a disciplinary process," Eckhard said.

"It means that they should not come onto the premises here unless it's in connection with summoning their defense, which they have 14 days to present in writing," he said.

After Sevan and Stephanides respond to the charges, the U.N. Secretariat headed by Annan will make a final decision on sanctions.

Eckhard said there are three options: the cases could be closed, Annan could decide to dismiss them, or the matter could be referred to the Joint Disciplinary Committee which would then make a recommendation to Annan.

Sevan and Stephanides are entitled to two appeals; the process can take months.

Annan said he was shocked by the findings of an investigation led by former U.S. Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker regarding Sevan. The secretary-general has said that if any of Volcker's findings lead to criminal charges, he would lift diplomatic immunity.


Eckhard noted Monday that Volcker is still investigating Sevan but has not alleged any criminal wrongdoing.

Sevan ran the oil-for-food program from 1996 until it ended in November 2003. He retired from the United Nations last year but remains on the payroll for $1 a year to help with the investigation. Stephanides is scheduled to retire in about five months.

Eckhard said their U.N. pensions cannot be touched.

The investigation led by Volcker accused Sevan in an interim report released Thursday of a "grave conflict of interest," saying his conduct in soliciting oil deals from Iraq was "ethically improper and seriously undermined the integrity of the United Nations."

Volcker did not say that Sevan received kickbacks, but expressed concern at $160,000 in cash which Sevan said he received from his aunt in his native Cyprus from 1999-2003. The report questioned this "unexplained wealth," noting that the aunt, who recently died, was a retired government photographer living on a modest pension.

Volcker said he is still investigating "the scope and extent of benefits" that Sevan received from his request that a small Swiss-based oil company, African Middle East Petroleum Co. Ltd. Inc., be given a chance to buy Iraqi oil.

Sevan's lawyer, Eric Lewis, accused Volcker's Independent Investigative Committee of trying to make his client a "scapegoat" and said "Mr. Sevan never took a penny." He said Sevan was proud of his 40-year U.N. career and of the oil-for-food program, which saved tens of thousands of Iraqis "from death by disease and starvation."

Under the program, Saddam Hussein's regime could sell oil, provided the proceeds went primarily to buy humanitarian goods and pay reparations to victims of the 1991 Gulf War. Saddam's government decided on the goods it wanted, who should provide them, and who could buy Iraqi oil. The U.N. Security Council committee overseeing sanctions monitored the contracts.

In a bid to curry favor and end sanctions, Saddam allegedly gave former government officials, activists, journalists and U.N. officials vouchers for Iraqi oil that could be resold at a profit.

Confirmation politics


Once again another liberal dem shows that he has no principles what so ever. Of course, "Chucky Cheese" Schumer never really did have any. His only concern is playing politics and principles be damned. - Sailor


Confirmation politics
Robert Novak February 7, 2005
townhall.com

WASHINGTON -- Sen. Charles Schumer of New York, intensely ambitious and partisan, was uncharacteristically caught off balance. He had worked so amiably on federal judgeships in his state with Alberto Gonzales as White House counsel that the senator effusively endorsed his nomination as attorney general. Now, weeks later, Schumer was not only criticizing Gonzales but opposing his confirmation.

How did a four-year relationship suddenly sour? There was no revelation about Gonzales causing scales to fall from Schumer's eyes. Instead, the inner circle of Senate Democrats determined that the previously non-controversial Mexican-American from Texas would be the prime target of President Bush's second term nominations. Schumer, caught leaning the wrong way on a party matter, recovered and was one of 35 Democrats (out of 41 present) plus one nominal independent who voted last Thursday against Gonzales.

This is confirmation politics, an especially noxious form of partisanship emerging during the current Bush presidency. Unlike the parallel Democratic campaign to block confirmation of conservative judges, there is no effort to prevent non-judicial nominees from taking office. Rather, it spotlights negative Bush issues -- prisoner abuse for Gonzales -- by attacking the failed policy's supposed architect.

The Democrats' course was tipped off Jan. 19 by Sen. Joseph Biden during Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearings on Condoleezza Rice's nomination as secretary of state. Biden, the committee's ranking Democrat, told Rice he would vote for her with "frustration" and "reservation" because "I believe strongly the president is entitled to his Cabinet." Yet, a week later, he opposed Gonzales in committee.

Actually, Biden has a long record of opposing Republican non-judicial nominees. In the elder George Bush's administration, he voted against John Tower for secretary of defense and Robert Gates for CIA director, as well as several lesser nominees.

Biden's propensity to vote no increased during the second Bush's administration as Senate Democrats, in the minority, used the confirmation process to underline issues. Far from giving the new president the benefit of the doubt, Biden in 2001 voted against John Ashcroft for attorney general, Gale Norton for secretary of the interior, Theodore Olson for solicitor general and John Bolton for under secretary of state.

The good-natured senator from Delaware was no lonely dissenter. At his side were such senior Democrats as Edward M. Kennedy of Massachusetts and Patrick Leahy of Vermont (joined by up-and-coming first-termers like Schumer). Sen. Harry Reid, the new minority leader who advocates a less partisan Senate, was a no-voter in every case except support for fellow Westerner Norton at Interior.

Democratic memoranda earlier revealed a coordinated campaign to derail Bush judges, and Senate sources say the party's stance on new Cabinet nominees also is orchestrated. Party leaders decided to use the debate on Rice to rehash Bush's Iraq policy without really opposing her confirmation, but to actually oppose Gonzales while trying to tie him to the Abu Ghraib prison scandal.

Of the six Democrats who broke party ranks to vote for Gonzales, five were from "red" states carried by Bush for president. The sixth was from "blue" Connecticut: Joseph Lieberman, 2000 nominee for vice president and 2004 candidate for the presidential nomination. Freed of national political ambitions, he can be Joe Lieberman again. In the most closely reasoned speech supporting Gonzales, he demolished the case against him.

Lieberman pointed out that the case was based on a Justice Department memo to Gonzales about illegal combatants. "I have to ask myself," Lieberman told the Senate, whether to deny confirmation "because of a memo written by somebody else." As for Gonzales's refusal to tell senators his comments to the president on the memo, Lieberman said, "I respect the right of the counsel of the president to keep private . . . the private counsel he gives to the president."

When I first covered the Senate 45 years ago, confirmation battles were rare. It was considered a stain on the Senate in 1959 when President Eisenhower's nominee for secretary of commerce was rejected because of one powerful Democratic senator's personal animus. Today, nothing is personal. President Bush's 2001 nominees were attacked because of their opinions and his 2005 nominees because of administration policies. The decline of the Senate continues.


Harry Reid's 'Roulette'


George Will takes on the dem hysteria over the Social Security plan that will allow workers to invest a small percent of their SS contributions into private accounts. As the President pointed out in his SOTU speech, federal employess already have a similar plan. - Sailor



Harry Reid's 'Roulette'

Members of Congress are doing very well indeed under a plan comparable to the one President Bush would allow all Americans to participate in.


By George F. Will
Newsweek


Feb. 14 issue - A century ago, American progressives said they aspired to use Hamiltonian means to achieve Jeffersonian ends. They meant they would wield a strong federal government to promote equality. One of George W. Bush's aims with Social Security reform, as with the rest of his "ownership society" agenda, is to use Hamiltonian means for Hamiltonian ends.

Bush wants to use bold federal measures such as voluntary personal retirement accounts, funded by 4 percentage points of Social Security taxes, to encourage citizens to be self-reliant, farsighted, thrifty, industrious and entrepreneurial. The Democratic Party, which traces its pedigree—although little of its current thinking—to Jefferson, likes Bush's idea as little as Jefferson liked Hamilton. What the Democrats currently lack, however, is a leader with even 4 percent of Jefferson's stature.

Last week Howard Dean, almost certainly the next Democratic Party chairman, said: "I hate Republicans and everything they stand for." Either Dean means what he says, in which case he is as unhinged as the rest of the party's Michael Moore caucus, or he does not, in which case he is a blowhard like, well, Moore. Yet for several weeks Dean has been one of the four most conspicuous Democrats on the national stage.

Two of the others have been Ted Kennedy, the shrill essence of East Coast liberalism, and California Sen. Barbara Boxer, who comes from Marin County, a habitat for West Coast liberals who find the city across the Golden Gate Bridge too tepidly "progressive." The fourth, and most important, is Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid, who seems determined to earn the description Teddy Roosevelt applied to President John Tyler—"a politician of monumental littleness."

In December, Reid, speaking about President Bush's proposal for Social Security reform—a proposal Bush had not yet announced—said: "[Republicans] are trying to destroy Social Security by giving this money to the fat cats on Wall Street." Good grief. "Destroy"? The "fat cats" will not get fatter from the estimated 0.3 percent cost of handling the funds.

Reid's hyperbole suggests that Deanspeak is contagious. In Reid's televised "response" to the president's State of the Union address—written before the address—he disparaged the idea of voluntary personal retirement accounts funded by portions of individuals' Social Security taxes as "Social Security roulette." This is the crux of the Democrats' argument against Bush's plan: Equities markets are terribly risky—indeed, are as irrational and risky as roulette. Think about that.


Roulette is a game without any element of skill. By comparing the investment of some Social Security funds in stocks and bonds to gambling on roulette, Reid is saying that the risks and rewards of America's capital markets, which are the foundation of the nation's economic rationality and prosperity, are as random as the caroms of the ball in a roulette wheel. This, from a national leader, is amazing.

It is especially so for a reason Bush delivered with a rhetorical rapier thrust in his State of the Union address. After saying that the 4 percentage points of Social Security taxes could be invested only in a few broadly diversified stock and bond funds, Bush pointedly said to the assembled representatives and senators: "Personal retirement accounts should be familiar to federal employees, because you already have something similar, called the Thrift Savings Plan, which lets workers deposit a portion of their paychecks into any of five different broadly based investment funds." Touché.

Begun in 1987, the Thrift Savings Plan, which as of December 2004 had assets of $152 billion, is a retirement-savings plan open to all civilian federal employees, including senators, and all members of the uniformed services.

They can invest as much as 14 percent of their salaries in one of five retirement funds. Consider the rate of return of C Fund, one of the five. It is a common-stock fund, so it should represent the risks that Reid thinks should terrify Americans:

In only four of 17 years has the rate of return been negative. But in 11 years the rate has been greater than 10 percent, in eight years it has been greater than 20 percent, in four years it has been greater than 30 percent. The compound annual rate of return for the last 10 years has been 12 percent, and the return over the 17 years has been 12.1 percent.

Reid participates in the plan, but opposes allowing all Americans the comparable opportunity that Bush is proposing. But if the numbers just cited are the result of roulette, the legislators should let the rest of us into the game in which they are prospering.

Patriots win 3rd Super Bowl in 4 years


Both teams are to be congratulated for providing the fans with a great game. Hats off to the Patriots and to their coach, Bill Belichick! - Sailor


Patriots win 3rd Super Bowl in 4 years
By Barry Wilner, AP Football Writer February 6, 2005

JACKSONVILLE, Fla. -- The New England Patriots don't have to proclaim greatness. The NFL record book does it for them. The Patriots won their third Super Bowl in four years Sunday, 24-21 over the Philadelphia Eagles, and now they are challenging history.

It was their ninth straight postseason victory, equaling Vince Lombardi's Green Bay Packers. It was coach Bill Belichick's 10th playoff victory in 11 games, one better than the great Lombardi. And it matched Dallas' run of three championships in four years in the early 1990s.

"We've never really self-proclaimed ourselves anything," said Tom Brady, who is 9-0 in the playoffs. "If you guys say we're great, we'll accept the compliment."

This one wasn't overpowering, and at times it was downright ugly. But not even Belichick seemed to care about that.

"To me this trophy belongs to these players," Belichick said. "They met all comers this year, a very challenging year. We're thrilled to win. These players played great all year, their best in the big games and they deserve it, they really deserve it."

With MVP Deion Branch tying a Super Bowl record for receptions with 11, Brady efficiently running the offense and Rodney Harrison sparking a smothering defense, the Patriots (17-2) didn't need a last-second field goal from Adam Vinatieri this time.

But his kick -- a 22-yarder with 8:40 left -- provided the points that made the difference.

This time, the Patriots sealed it with a stop.

Philadelphia (15-4) got the ball back at its 4 with 46 seconds remaining. It was hardly enough time and far too much territory to cover against such a formidable foe.

Harrison got his second interception with 9 seconds remaining to end it.

Playing before a sea of mostly green jerseys in the crowd of 78,125, the Patriots ended Philadelphia's chance of heading north with its first pro sports title since 1983. Indeed, it's been 45 years since the Eagles won the NFL crown. And even though they made it to the Super Bowl for the first time since 1981 -- after three straight conference championship flops -- their sparkling season still ended in disappointment.

"We were too sloppy to win," receiver Terrell Owens said. "It was great to get back, but we made too many mistakes. We could have won and that hurts."

Corey Dillon, a newcomer to the championship game, scored the go-ahead points on a 2-yard run early in the fourth period. And when Branch wasn't catching passes, the Patriots flaunted their versatility by again using linebacker Mike Vrabel to find the end zone.

Vrabel has caught TD passes in two straight Super Bowls and has five TDs in as many career catches, not bad for a linebacker -- or anyone else.

Brady wasn't as fluid as he was when he won the MVP awards in the 2002 and 2004 games, but he was 23-for-33 for 236 yards and two TDs.

"It doesn't matter who gets what," Branch said of taking the MVP away from his quarterback.

When the offense bogged down or turned over the ball, Harrison and his mates forced four turnovers, including a goal-line interception by the veteran safety. The Patriots also had four sacks, making Donovan McNabb look ordinary, even skittish at times.

And while Owens' return from a seven-week injury layoff was an individual success -- he had nine catches for 122 yards -- it was not nearly the star turn that Branch made.

Branch was most instrumental on the opening drive of the second half, which set the tone for New England's 57th victory in its last 74 games.

While New England handled frequent blitzes, Branch caught four passes for 71 yards on the series that ended with Vrabel's TD.

"We did a great job of adjusting during the game," Branch said. "It was physical; a lot of guys were bumped and bruised."

The Eagles responded with a 74-yard drive. McNabb whipped a 10-yard pass over the middle between two defenders to Brian Westbrook for the TD.

Still, as winners always do, the Patriots reasserted themselves, effectively using screen passes against a tiring defense. Even when Eagles defenders shouted to each other to watch for the screen, New England made it work, particularly on Kevin Faulk's 14-yarder that preceded Dillon's 2-yard run to make it 21-14.

Vinatieri hit his chip shot to make it 24-14. The Eagles came back on Greg Lewis' 30-yard TD reception with 1:48 remaining.

Not that it bothered the Patriots, not that anything seems to bother the Patriots. Here's a team that's losing offensive coordinator Charlie Weis to Notre Dame and defensive coordinator Romeo Crennel to become Cleveland's coach.

"When you're in the middle of it, you're not thinking about what you're doing," Weis said. "Dynasties are talked about 10 years later."

Sorry, Charlie, the Patriots are the talk of the league now.

The victory gave New England its second team championship since the fall, though this was hardly as dramatic as the long-suffering Red Sox winning the World Series. Still, this certifies Boston as the hub of champions.

Philadelphia's title drought goes on, but Owens certainly did his best to end it. The All-Pro receiver fulfilled his vow to start the Super Bowl, defying his doctor and playing with a metal plate and two screws in his right ankle.

"T.O. did a heck of a job," coach Andy Reid said. "I was proud of the effort and they battled, but we came up just short -- too many turnovers -- and against such a tough football team you can't do that."

Replay played a significant role on the first series. McNabb dropped the ball when he was hit by Willie McGinest and New England recovered at the Philadelphia 34. But Reid challenged that McNabb's knee was down when hit seconds before by Tedy Bruschi.

Replay showed McNabb, indeed, was down.

Philly put together the first good drive late in the opening period. Owens got open on a crossing pattern and gained 30 yards on third down, with a roughing penalty adding 9 yards, but a 16-yard sack by Mike Vrabel set back the Eagles.

Then McNabb threw a poor pass that Asante Samuel intercepted in the end zone, only to have it overturned because of illegal contact by linebacker Roman Phifer.

No matter. McNabb again threw a duck, which Harrison picked off at the 3.

But the Eagles got the ball again at the New England 45 after a punt. Three plays later, another turnover: Randall Gay knocked the ball loose from L.J. Smith and Samuel recovered at the 38.

Once more, the defense held, and when the Eagles got the ball back at their 19, they finally finished off a drive.

Todd Pinkston, often overshadowed by Owens, looked like his illustrious teammate on receptions of 17 and 40 yards. On the longer one, he soared high for yet another misthrow by McNabb and took it away from Gay.

On third down from the 6, McNabb hung in the pocket and waited for Smith to get free in the end zone for the game's first score with 9:55 left in the half.

It was the first time New England trailed this postseason.

Brady then made a rare mistake, fumbling at the Philly 13. Darwin Walker recovered New England's first giveaway of the postseason.

It didn't lead to anything for the Eagles, and after a 29-yard punt by Dirk Johnson, the Pats drove 37 yards to tie it at 7. Brady found Givens behind Lito Sheppard in the right corner of the end zone for a 4-yard score, and Givens mocked Owens' wing flap after the touchdown with 1:10 remaining.

UN Critic Says Scandal Indicates Breakdown in Security Council Mission


Yet another critic of the UN finds that the Oil-for-Food scandal was more then just a scam. It was how saddam was able to buy influence on the Security Council itself. The UN continues to become less and less relavent every day. - Sailor




UN Critic Says Scandal Indicates Breakdown in Security Council Mission
By Julie Stahl
CNSNews.com Jerusalem Bureau Chief
February 04, 2005

Jerusalem (CNSNews.com) - The U.N.'s oil-for-food scandal points to a breakdown in the Security Council's mandate to safeguard international peace and security, says a former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations.

Dr. Dore Gold, author of the recently released "Tower of Babble: How the United Nations Has Fueled Global Chaos" said that beyond the corruption aspect of the scandal, there has not been enough focus on the breach of international security.

A panel appointed to investigate the U.N.'s oil-for-food program found that Saddam Hussein and others were able to siphon billions of dollars out of the program because mismanagement and a failure to follow accounting procedures.

U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan says he has started disciplinary proceedings against the U.N. official who ran the program. An interim report released Thursday said Benon Sevan had a "grave and continuing conflict of interest" and "seriously undermined the integrity of the United Nations."

A separate report addressing questions about the possible involvement of Annan and his son Kojo is yet to come.

"The oil-for-food program corruption story has probably jolted the foundations of the U.N. more than any other recent scandal," Gold told the Cybercast News Service in an interview conducted prior to the release of Thursday's interim report.

"The reason is not because of the corruption, which many in the press are focusing on...but I think what is striking many is that the oil-for-food program was a mechanism by which Saddam Hussein could funnel money to countries and individuals that would support him in the U.N. Security Council."

Gold served as Israel's ambassador to the U.N. from mid-1997 until the end of 1999.

An earlier report -- from the U.S. government's Iraq Survey Group -- charged that Saddam had subverted the oil-for-food program in an attempt to bribe French and Russian officials and companies to use their influence on behalf of Iraq as permanent members of the Security Council.

France and Russia were two of Iraq's staunchest supporters in the Security Council.

"What the scandal really points to is a fundamental breakdown of the Security Council as a guarantor of international peace and security since it seems from initial findings to be a body that can be so easily manipulated by a determined oil-producing country," he said.

Another element of the security failure was that the U.N.'s hiring of a Swiss company - Cotechna - which in turn paid Annan's son Kojo. The company was responsible for monitoring and inspecting what was entering Iraq from Syria and Jordan.

But according to U.N. internal audits, the company did not hire sufficient staff to ensure that foodstuffs and pharmaceuticals were being trucked into Iraq rather than industrial goods that could be used for the Iraqi military, Gold said.

"The U.S. Congress estimated that only seven to 10 percent of all goods coming into Iraq under the oil-for-food program were inspected. That means that there was a gaping hole that had been created in this program through which Saddam Hussein could bring illicit goods," Gold said.

According to Gold, the oil-for-food program allowed Saddam to funnel money into his military industry and increase its budget 100-fold from 1996 to 2003.

"Clearly Saddam Hussein was preparing the groundwork to reconstitute many of his weapons programs," Gold said.

And because the U.N. oil-for-food program failed to inspect goods coming into Iraq -- and because Saddam Hussein manipulated the program, funneling money into his military - the "U.N. failed in its mission to the international community," Gold added.

Sunday, February 06, 2005

At Ease, Gen Mattis!


They tell you that it is the uniform your salute and not necessarily the man. In this case, this Sailor throws General Mattis, my best parade ground salute. The man as well as the uniform! - Sailor


At Ease, Gen Mattis!

By Ralph Kinney Bennett
Published
02/05/2005
Tech Central Station






To delight in war is a merit in the soldier, a dangerous quality in the captain, and a positive crime in the statesman.

-- George Santayana



I'd heard of U.S. Marine Gen. Jim Mattis from other Marines over the years and from news coverage of his own exploits. He was the blunt, bachelor general who had served nine tours of duty in the Middle East, including combat in Afghanistan and Iraq.



He was the commander of the 1st Marine Division in the longest, fastest thrust of a division in Corps history -- that dash to Baghdad in 2003.



I knew he wasn't just an officer; he was a leader.



And a fighter.



Not a statesman. Not an orator. No, God love him, he's a fighter.



In the military it has always been true that what you see is not always what you get. The "salad" on the uniform chest often bears closer inspection. It may be the fruit of the career of a gifted bureaucrat, a crypto-politician, a superb manager, or a combination of these.



Nothing wrong with that. Our vast military establishment needs all of the above in varying ways and to varying degrees.



But it also needs leaders who are fighters. Those who will kick down the door. Those who will get the job done. As we have observed here before, all the niceties of democracy and civilization depend from time to time on a few men who will go down dark streets and do uncivilized and possibly undemocratic things we would rather not think about, let alone talk about.



Well, General Mattis talked about it. A little.



It was in San Diego last week, at a conference hosted by the Armed Forces Communications and Electronics Association and the U.S. Naval Institute. There were lots of military types in the room. They were discussing what changes our military must make to battle terrorists in future wars.



General Mattis pointed out to fellow conferees that, capable as we are of fighting "modern wars," we are having trouble adapting to "historic forms of warfare" brought back by the terrorists in Iraq and Afghanistan.



The general warned, "Don't patronize this enemy. They mean business. They mean every word they say. Don't imagine an enemy somewhere in the future and you're going to transform so you can fight him. They're killing us now. Their will is not broken."



Of course, General Mattis knows whereof he speaks. He's been there, doing that. And it was while reflecting on this that he made the following remark:



"Actually, it's quite fun to fight'em, you know. It's a hell of a hoot. It's fun to shoot some people. I'll be right up front with you. I like brawling."



The general then made clear who "some people" are. "You go into Afghanistan. You've got guys who slapped women around for five years because they didn't wear a veil. You know guys like that ain't got no manhood left anyway. So it's a hell of a lot of fun to shoot them."



These remarks sent a predictable shudder through the press. A story from The Washington Post news service noted that the general's blunt words had "sparked criticism from military ethicists."



Military ethicists.



At Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld's press conference, Thursday, which centered on serious issues like the Iraqi vote and continuing security difficulties, the first question from the press was a fussy inquiry about the "appropriateness" of General Mattis' remarks.



Rumsfeld and Marine Gen. Peter Pace, vice-chairman of the Joint Chiefs, somehow refrained from bitch slapping the reporter and moved on to more important matters.



Marine Commandant Gen. Michael Hagee, to his immense credit, called General Mattis "one of this country's bravest and most experienced military leaders" and noted that he had merely been trying to "reflect the unfortunate and harsh realities of war."



To close the matter, General Hagee said, "I have counseled (Mattis) concerning his remarks and he agrees he should have chosen his words more carefully." (For more on all this from a Marine, check the always superb www.theadventuresofchester.com.)



It turns out there actually are "military ethicists." One of them, Jeff McCausland, director of the Leadership in Conflict Initiative (at Dickinson College, Carlisle, Pa.) called General Mattis' remarks "unprofessional and inappropriate" and noted that they send a "terrible message" to those serving under him.



If any "terrible message" has been sent, it has been by the bombings and butchery of the terrorists and Islamofanatics. These are General Mattis' "guy's like that," who treat women as beneath contempt, gleefully slit throats and behead innocents before cameras, stop buses on lonely roads and execute the young men inside, murder in the streets for the world to see.



It is the civilized part of us that is always a little uneasy with our General Pattons, but in the end most of us cut them some slack. We know deep in our hearts what they really mean. There's a rough and half humorous hyperbole in General Mattis' words -- the language that cops know, and firemen, when they talk among themselves.



But I see an old fashioned gallantry, too, in those words. They are his blunt affirmation that he has fought in a war worth fighting against an uncivilized enemy that deserves to be destroyed. They tell us that he fights with élan and, I think, high purpose.



At ease, General Mattis. Your country salutes you… and needs you.

A Scam in Your Mailbox


This is brought to you as a public service from this Sailor. If you receive an e-mail promising mega bucks and asking you for any personal information, such as bank account numbers, phone number, etc., report it immediately to your e-mail provider and local law enforcement. - Sailor


A Scam in Your Mailbox
Bruce Mandelblit
Saturday, Feb. 5, 2005
NewsMax.com

You have probably received these dozens of times, perhaps in the mail or even delivered through e-mail. Chain letters have been a swindle for many long years – but even today thousands of folks are still schemed by their "get rich quick" promises. For instance, I recently received two chain letter offers just hours apart, one in the mail and the other via e-mail. Amazing!

Most chain letters are generally set up in the same way. First of all, they promise a large cash return on a very small investment. The letter or e-mail usually contains a list of names and addresses, with instructions that you send a few dollars (generally $5) to the person at the top of the list, then remove that name from the list and add your own name to the bottom of the list. Next, the chain letter may request that you mail or e-mail copies of the letter to a certain number of people, along with the directions on how they should continue the chain letter.

The chain letter attempts to hook you with this alluring premise – by the time your name gets to the top of the list, so many people will be involved that you will be deluged with cash. For example, a common chain letter promises earnings of $50,000 or more within the next 90 days!

There's at least one problem with that assurance – chain letters are illegal if they request money or other items of value, and promise a substantial return to the participant. Oops!

Today, chain letters have gone high-tech. They are being disseminated over the Internet, or they may require the copying and mailing of computer disks.

A Quick Security Tip: According to the Untied States Postal Inspection Service, regardless of what technology is used to advance the scheme, if the mail is used at any step along the way, it is still illegal.

Here are some chain letter awareness tips from the FTC:

1. Chain letters that involve money or valuable items and promise big returns are illegal. If you start one or send one on, you are breaking the law.

2. Chances are you will receive little or no money back on your "investment." Despite the claims, a chain letter will never make you rich.

3. Some chain letters try to win your confidence by claiming they are legal, and even that they are endorsed by the government. Nothing is further from the truth.

Quick Security Tip: Neither the Postal Service nor the [ostal inspectors give prior approval to any chain letter!

4. If you have been a target of a chain e-mail scam, contact your Internet Service Provider and forward the e-mail to the FTC at uce@ftc.gov.

In addition, the Postal Inspection Service offers the following chain letter advice:

1. Chain letters don't work because the promise that all participants in a chain letter will be winners is mathematically impossible.

2. Do not be fooled if the chain letter is used to sell inexpensive reports on credit, mail order sales, mailing lists or other topics. The primary purpose is to take your money, not to sell information.

A Quick Security Tip: "Selling" a product does not ensure legality of a chain letter.

3. Turn over any chain letter you receive that asks for money or other items of value to your local postmaster or nearest postal inspector.

A Quick Security Tip: Write on the mailing envelope of the letter, "I have received this in the mail and believe it may be illegal."

For more information about chain letters, please contact the FTC at www.ftc.gov and the Postal Inspection Service at www.usps.com.

My Final Thoughts: With today's uncertain economic conditions, including high unemployment, it is highly likely that you will receive more "get rich quick" cons than ever, including illegal chain letters.

Don't get duped – always carefully check out any offers BEFORE you invest your hard-earned dollars!

(Note: If you manufacture or distribute any Security, Safety, Emergency Preparedness or Crime Prevention related products, please send information on your product line for possible future reference in this column to: CrimePrevention123@yahoo.com.)


* * * * * *
Copyright 2005 by Bruce Mandelblit

"Staying Safe" with Bruce Mandelblit is a regular column for the readers of NewsMax.com and NewsMax.com Magazine.

Bruce welcomes your thoughts. His e-mail address is: CrimePrevention123@yahoo.com.

Bruce is a nationally known security journalist, as well as a recently retired, highly decorated reserve Law Enforcement Officer.

Bruce writes Staying Safe, a weekly syndicated column covering the topics of security, safety and crime prevention.

Bruce was commissioned as a Kentucky Colonel – the state's highest honor – for his public service.

This column is provided for general information purposes only. Please check with your local law enforcement agency and legal professional for information specific to you and your jurisdiction.

Would you trust these men with $64bn of your cash?


Mark Steyn answers this question as only he can. The UN is a cesspool of corruption and incompetence. Either the UN gets fixed or it is time for it to fade away into history as the failed organization it is. - Sailor


Would you trust these men with $64bn of your cash? Of course not

By Mark Steyn
(Filed: 06/02/2005)
opinion.telegraph

At tough times in my life, with the landlord tossing my clothes and record collection out on to the street, I could have used an aunt like Benon Sevan's. Asked to account for the appearance in his bank account of a certain $160,000, Mr Sevan, executive director of the UN Oil-for-Food programme, said it was a gift from his aunt. Lucky Sevan, eh? None of my aunts ever had that much of the folding stuff on tap.

And nor, it seems, did Mr Sevan's. She lived in a modest two-room flat back in Cyprus and her own bank accounts gave no indication of spare six-figure sums. Nonetheless, if a respected UN diplomat says he got 160,000 bucks from Auntie, we'll just have to take his word for it. Paul Volcker's committee of investigation did plan to ask the old lady to confirm her nephew's version of events, but, before they could, she fell down an elevator shaft and died.

If you're a UN bigshot, or the son of Kofi Annan, or the cousin of Boutros Boutros-Ghali, or any of the other well-connected guys on the Oil-for-Fraud payroll, $160,000 is pretty small beer. But, if you're a starving kid in Ramadi or Nasariyah, it would go quite a long way. Instead, the starving-kid money went a long way in the opposite direction, to the Swiss bank accounts of Saddam's apologists. "The Secretary-General is shocked by what the report has to say about Mr Sevan," declared Kofi Annan's chief of staff, Britain's own Mark Malloch Brown.

That's how bad things are at the UN: even the Brits sound like Claude Rains. Of course, the Secretary-General isn't "shocked" at all. And nor are the media, which is why the major news organisations can barely contain their boredom with the biggest financial scam of all time – bigger than Enron, Worldcom and all the rest rolled into one. If ever there were a dog-bites-man story, "UN Stinkingly Corrupt Shock!" is it.

And, in a way, they have a point: what happened was utterly predictable. If I had $64 billion of my own money, I'd look after it carefully. But give someone $64 billion of other people's money to "process" and it would be surprising if some of it didn't get peeled off en route. Especially if that $64 billion gives you access to a unique supply of specially low-priced oil you can re-sell at market prices. Hire Third World bureaucrats to supervise the "processing" and you can kiss even more of it goodbye. Grant Saddam Hussein the right of approval over the bank that will run the scheme, and it's clear to all that nit-picky book-keeping will not be an overburdensome problem.

In other words, the system didn't fail. This is the transnational system, working as it usually works, just a little more so. One of the reasons I'm in favour of small government is because big government tends to be remote government, and remote government is unaccountable, and, as a wannabe world government, the UN is the remotest and most unaccountable of all. If the sentimental utopian blather ever came true and we wound up with one "world government", from an accounting department point of view, the model will be Nigeria rather than New Hampshire.

That's why Washington has no interest in joining Gordon Brown's newly announced Cash-for-Guilt programme, under which the Chancellor (or, to be more precise, you) has agreed to improve the Afro-kleptocracy's cash flow by transferring 10 per cent of its debt burden to the United Kingdom – a perfect example of the malign combination of empty European gesture-politics and Third World larceny that's been the default mode of progressive transnationalism for far too long. By contrast, consider the splendid John Howard. In announcing Australian's $1 billion tsunami aid package, he was careful to emphasise that he wouldn't be wiring it via the estate of Benon Sevan's late auntie.

If Paul Volcker's preliminary report on Oil-for-Food dealt with the organisation's unofficial interests, the UN's other report of the week accurately captured their blithe insouciance to their official one. As you may have noticed, the good people of Darfur have been fortunate enough not to attract the attention of the arrogant cowboy unilateralist Bush and have instead fallen under the care of the Polly Toynbee-Clare Short-approved multilateral compassion set. So, after months of expressing deep concern, grave concern, deep concern over the graves and deep grave concern over whether the graves were deep enough, Kofi Annan managed to persuade the UN to set up a committee to look into what's going on in Darfur. They've just reported back that it's not genocide.

That's great news, isn't it? For as yet another Annan-appointed UN committee boldly declared in December: "Genocide anywhere is a threat to the security of all and should never be tolerated." So thank goodness this isn't genocide. Instead, it's just 70,000 corpses who all happen to be from the same ethnic group – which means the UN can go on tolerating it until everyone's dead, and Polly and Clare don't have to worry their pretty little heads about it.

That's the transnational establishment's alternative to Bush and Howard: appoint a committee that agrees on the need to do nothing. Thus, a few days ago, the UN Human Rights Commission announced the working group that will decide which complaints will be heard at their annual meeting in Geneva this spring: the five-nation panel comprises the Netherlands, Hungary, Cuba, Saudi Arabia and Zimbabwe. I wouldn't bet on them finding room on their crowded agenda for the question of human rights in Cuba, Saudi Arabia and Zimbabwe, would you? One of the mystifying aspects of UN worship is the assumption that this embryo world government is a "progressive" concept. It's not. Its squalid geographic voting blocs, which use regional solidarity to inflate the status of nickel'n'dime dictators, are merely a Third World gloss on the Congress of Vienna – a relic of an age when contact between states was confined to their governing elites. In an era of jet travel, internet and debit cards that work in any bank machine from Vancouver to Vilnius to Vanuatu, there are millions of global relationships far better for the long-term health of the planet than using American money to set up Eurowimp talking shops manned by African thugs – which is what the UN Human Rights Commission boils down to.

The Bush Administration is now said to be considering using Kofi's "shock" to effect a regime change of its own at the UN. But to whom and to what? I'd be in favour of destroying the UN – or, failing that, at least moving its headquarters to Rwanda, but either of those options would require a level of political will hard to muster in modern sentimental democracies.

The best alternative to the trans‐national jet-set is nothing – or at least nothing formal. When the tsunami hit, the Americans and Australians had troops and relief supplies on the ground within hours and were coordinating their efforts without any global bureaucracy at all. Imagine that: an unprecedented disaster, and yet robust, efficient, compatible, results-oriented nations managed to accomplish more than the international system specifically set up to manage such events. Would it have helped to elect a steering committee with Sudan and Zimbabwe on it? Of course not. But, if the UN wants to hold meetings, hector Washington, steal money and give tacit approval to genocide, let it – and let it sink into irrelevance.

Saturday, February 05, 2005

The Green "State of Fear"


Michael Crichton's "Sate of Fear" is a definite must read. In this article, Suzanne Fields, points out what Michael Crichton is really all about. - Sailor.



The Green "State of Fear"
By Suzanne Fields
Townhall.com February 4, 2005

Michael Crichton is a high-tech, science-savvy Renaissance man in the 21st century. He has sold more than a hundred million books, which have been translated into 30 languages. Twelve became high-grossing movies. Children everywhere have "Jurassic Park" nightmares.

His books are so popular in China that when the calcified remains of a species of dinosaur was discovered there, the Chinese named it Bienosauraus crichtoni in his honor. In 1992, People magazine named him one of the "Fifty Most Beautiful People."

Now a new kind of fame brings Michael Crichton to Washington to speak to policy wonks. He's promoting his new book, "State of Fear," which zoomed to the top of the bestseller lists, but he doesn't come to Washington to talk about the novel.

Not long ago his speech, "Science Policy in the 21st Century," was sponsored by two think tanks, the American Enterprise Institute and Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies, and it's about what he thinks about environmentalists in general, and climate change in particular. He has a lot of thoughts about the way science influences public policy.

He minces no words. What passes for science by so-called experts in the debate over "global warming," he says, influences policy that is based on faulty data and ideological considerations. This does considerably more damage than good.

Ideology drives the scientists who get the grants to conduct research; the government agency that gives grants is driven by politics. In the novel, a page-turning action thriller, major characters, including a scientist, a lawyer, a philanthropist and two gorgeous women, are superheroes who foil the devices of environmental extremists, evil missionaries with messianic drives, pushing policies born of their own egos.

In a novel twist on the novel, the author appends footnotes and a bibliography to document scientific reports, and two hard-hitting essays explaining how and why politicized science is dangerous.

He compares the science of the environmentalists as similar to that of the study of eugenics a century ago. The study of eugenics, the idea that the human race could be "improved" by selective breeding, was at first supported by presidents, Nobel laureates, major universities, the Carnegie and Rockefeller Foundations, and together they molded public opinion. The science was insidious, pseudo-, and wrong.

Eugenics, recognized nearly everywhere now as both morally and criminally wrong, led directly to the Holocaust, with the Nazis killing first the feeble-minded, and ultimately extended to include Jews, Gypsies and homosexuals. Those who opposed eugenics were reactionary, ignorant or both. Research motivated by racism, fear of immigrants and "keeping the wrong people out of the neighborhood," drew few protests.

Michael Crichton argues that many environmental studies today are similarly flawed, directed by scientists who shape their research to fit the cause, and read by an ill-informed public duped to believe that scientific papers are "objective."

He cites an editorial in The Washington Post, which suggests adopting a policy change in climate control as "a sign of goodwill" to Europe. He notes, with irony and dismay, that the editorial appeared on the day that a dispatch from Auschwitz detailed the observance of the 60th anniversary of the liberation of the infamous death camp. Auschwitz, he says, was a direct descendent of politicized science.

Environmental grants, he argues, should go to several scientists working on a project with opposing points of view. Their work should be subjected to mutual criticism. "We need face-to-face dissent." The results should be made public: "The people paid for it, the people own it."

Only ruthless arguments can get to verifiable facts. Congressional hearings on scientific matters, he observes, are mostly dog-and-pony shows where questions are either "soft balls or hand grenades." Congressmen are eager to show off what their staffs have found for them, and ideologues want to persuade. This is a dangerous way to make policy.

He cites the story of the pesticide DDT, effective against many disease-carrying insects, as an example of environmentalism gone awry. DDT, he argues, was falsely accused of causing cancer, and because it was banned millions, mostly children, have died of disease and their deaths "are directly attributable to a callous, technologically advanced western society that promoted the new cause of environmentalism by pushing a fantasy about a pesticide, and irrevocably harmed the third world."

Environmentalism, he says, is "the religion of choice for urban atheists."
Such heresy won't be as popular as his novels and movies, but in the long run, may have the impact of DDT on a mosquito.

Media are Easy Marks


Jack Kelly points out how the media is such an easy marks for hoaxes. In the Sailor's opinion, the MSM drools to have negative news from Iraq and are quick to bring it out, without bothering to check the facts. Mr. Kelly also mentions the outrageous comments of Eason Jordan. Seems there are finally some cracks in the MSM's "wall of silence". (Note: Hugh Hewitt will be appearing on the Chris Matthews and Chris Wallace shows. Check your local listings for times and stations.) - Sailor


Media are easy marks
Jack Kelly
Toledo Blade


HISTORY repeats itself, Karl Marx said, "first as tragedy, second as farce."
In the days immediately following Iraq's historic election, two videotapes from "insurgent" groups were distributed to the news media. One purported to show an American soldier being held hostage. The second purported to show that a British C-130 transport aircraft, which crashed on election day, had been shot down by a surface-to-air missile.

The "American soldier" was Cody, a G.I. Joe action figure. This is obvious from the picture, but the Associated Press and CNN bit hard.

The cause of the C-130 crash is still being investigated. But experts at Jane's Defence Weekly have doubts about the claim of "insurgents."

"The missile footage has just been grafted onto the front," said editor Peter Felstead. "And it looks like a surface to surface missile to me."

Other experts note the wreckage footage was shot in daylight, while the C-130 crashed just before nightfall. It is highly improbable "insurgents" could have been on the scene before the sun set, and there were British soldiers all around the next morning.

Media outlets that were quick to report the insurgents' claims had little to say about the hoaxes. Nor did they speculate on what the hoaxes might mean.

Last Sunday's election demonstrated the massive support of the Iraqi people for democracy, and the relative impotence of the "insurgents." The "river of blood" they promised was barely a trickle.

Eight suicide bombers killed 36 Iraqis besides themselves. Of these, seven were foreigners (six Saudis and a Sudanese). The only Iraqi suicide bomber was a child suffering from Down syndrome. That is, as the Iraqi writer Nibras Kazimi put it, "eight against 8 million." And on what basis, one might ask, do the media call seven foreign terrorists "insurgents"?

The terrorists had to do something to revive their plummeting prestige. That they resorted to clumsy frauds is not a sign of strength.

"The captured toy story could be pretty significant," said the Web logger John Hinderaker (Power Line). "The terrorists need, more than anything else, to be seen as awesome, terrible figures. If they stop inspiring fear, they are finished. So the one thing they cannot stand is ridicule. Their pathetic effort to pass a doll off as a captured American soldier will [make] them laughingstocks throughout the Arab world."

It's also interesting that the terrorists turned to the news media to recover lost momentum. Journalists who fell for these hoaxes may merely be idiots, and their silence about the implications of the hoaxes may simply be the by-product of embarrassment. But more to the point, why are major media so quick to disseminate anything that a terrorist group, or purported terrorist group, releases? For the terrorist, it is like being given millions of dollars in free advertising.

The major media have from the beginning exaggerated the strength and popularity of those they mislabel "insurgents," to the disgust of American soldiers.

"I'm tired of hearing the crap, the whole, well 'We are barely hanging on, we're losing, the insurgency is growing,'●" Marine Sgt. Kevin Lewis told Dan Rather, in Iraq for the election. "It's just a small amount of people out there causing the problems. It's a small number, and we're killing them."

The scandalous remarks of Eason Jordan, CNN's top news executive, last week at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, and the failure of the major media to report them suggest the distortions are deliberate.

Mr. Jordan told a panel that the U.S. military had killed a dozen journalists in Iraq, and that they had been deliberately targeted. When challenged, Mr. Jordan could provide no evidence to support the charge, and subsequently lied about having made it, though the record shows he had made a similar charge a few months before, and also earlier had falsely accused the Israeli military of targeting journalists.

Mr. Jordan's slander has created a firestorm in the blogosphere, but has yet to be mentioned in the "mainstream" media.


Gee, I wonder why not.

Hard Times......and ever-moving goalposts.




Another take on how the left is trying to make the Iraqi elections look like a negative. - Sailor


4 February, 2005
Hard Times...
...and ever-moving goalposts.
Jonah Goldberg
nationalreview.com

"Forty-five dead — that's not peanuts," veteran journalist Donatella Lorch told the Washington Post, referring to the number of casualties in the wake of the Iraqi elections. "If that had happened in the United States on Election Day, we would have made it a major scandal. Now we're acting like in Iraq it's a great success. We seem to have become numb to the daily car bombs and daily attacks."


Yes, that's true. If in fact 45 people were killed on their way to the polls in America, it would be a "major scandal." Who can argue with that? In the "Well, duh!" department, Ms. Lorch's comment ranks just a few notches below the illuminating observation that bears habitually use our national forests to go potty.

Of course we all recoil at the murderous attacks last Sunday. But that's a point about trees. The forest is over here: Roughly eight million Iraqis went to the polls — largely on foot — to vote in the face of very, very credible threats that their children would be murdered, their families slaughtered, their homes blown up if they did so. By this one act, they robbed the insurgents of any claim to be the "authentic voice" of Iraq. Their motives for voting were no doubt a mix of the parochial and the idealistic, but one overriding reason they voted was that they could. And they could for only one reason: The United States and its allies had toppled Saddam and had stayed put to prevent a civil war and foster democracy.

A foreign-policy realist might have said, "Oops, no WMDs" — and then bugged out. We called Saddam's bluff, which was our perfect right given the stakes, but it's not in our interests to stay. That's realism. And it's funny to hear Ted Kennedy, Michael Moore, et al. keep invoking it.

Bush decided to stay partly out of a different realist analysis of our national interest: A democratic Middle East, he believes, is the best chance for stopping the production of terrorists.

But we also stayed as a matter of honor. In the run-up to war, according to Bob Woodward, Colin Powell allegedly coined the "Pottery Barn rule," which holds that if "you break it, you bought it." Saying, in other words, that we'd be obliged to fix Iraq if we broke it. The press loved this phrase because — they believed — it was so pregnant with I-told-you-sos.

Fair enough. But keep two things in mind. First, Iraq was already broken — broken by a madman responsible for unspeakable crimes inside Iraq and out. Second, the Pottery Barn rule is merely a pedantic way of saying that America is honor-bound to fulfill its commitments and act on its ideals. Ted Kennedy and Iraqi Sunnis demand that America fix a timetable for withdrawing from Iraq as if honor is an installment plan one can abandon when it gets too hard.

Bush has another view, which he made clear during the State of the Union: "We are in Iraq to achieve a result: A country that is democratic, representative of all its people, at peace with its neighbors, and able to defend itself. And when that result is achieved, our men and women serving in Iraq will return home with the honor they have earned."

All of this runs counter to the political headwind Bush has been marching into from the outset of the war. Every setback has been a disaster, proof of a "quagmire" or "imperial hubris." And every success has been greeted by a smug declaration that "this was the easy part" and the "hard part is next." Well, here's some news: It's all been hard. Toppling Hussein was hard. Creating the interim government was hard. Building hospitals, schools, and soccer fields: all hard.

All of the sophisticates and cynics insisted that having elections would be a bloody fool's errand. Bush was being too rigid by holding firm on the January elections. Surely a more reasonable man would postpone them since everyone knows they'll be a bloodbath. And then, once they took place, the goalposts were moved again.

Consider Juan Cole. You probably haven't heard of him, but he's the dashboard saint of lefty Middle East experts. President-elect of the Middle East Studies Association, Cole has made a new career for himself in finding the dark lining of every silver cloud. After the Iraqi elections he harrumphed on his Web site that he was "appalled" by the media's cheerleading of the election. He absurdly declared that the 1997 Iranian elections were much more democratic (Iranian candidates had to be approved by the mullahs). He whined that Bush did not originally intend to have elections of this sort and only agreed when Ayatollah Sistani insisted. Suddenly, Bush the rigid ideologue is too flexible.

Most telling, Cole offered a world-weary sigh that "This thing was more like a referendum than an election."

This observation requires us to reopen the "Well, duh!" list for a new contender. Of course it was more like a referendum. That's the point.

Real question is, how did prof get on CU's faculty in first place?


A good question indeed. Though the answer may be rather simple. Leftists are always welcome on campuses and one claiming to be a minority is embraced with open arms. Chruchill's claim to be part Indian have been debunked by the Kiowa Council. Pail Campos looks into the how and why Churchill was even hired. - Sailor



Campos: Real question is, how did prof get on CU's faculty in first place?
By Paul Campos
February 5, 2005
Rocky Mountain News

Should a serious research university consider hiring a fascist? This question doesn't have an easy answer.
After all, prior to World War II Europe produced several brilliant political theorists and philosophers who could be characterized as fascists, or proto-fascists, including Joseph de Maistre, Carl Schmitt and Martin Heidegger.


Whether, post- Auschwitz, it's possible even in theory to advocate similar views in intellectually plausible ways is an interesting question.

It is not, however, a question that has any relevance to the case of University of Colorado professor Ward Churchill, despite the obvious fascistic streak in Churchill's writings and public performances.
As a political inclination and an aesthetic style, fascism is marked by, among other things, the following characteristics:

• The worship of violence as a purifying social force. This often manifests itself as an aggressive and romanticized militarism, that produces a kind of cult of the warrior, and that advocates violent action as a mechanism for social change, and an appropriate way of crushing dissent.

• A hyper-nationalistic ideology, that casts history into a drama featuring an inevitably violent struggle between Good and Evil, and that obsesses on questions of racial and ethnic identity.

• The dehumanization and scapegoating of opponents, who are characterized by turns as demonically clever conspirators plotting to undermine the possibility of a virtuous society, and soulless automatons mindlessly carrying out the orders of a vast and evil bureaucracy. This dehumanization often leads to demands that the evil in our midst be eradicated "by any means necessary," up to and including the mass extermination of entire nations and peoples.

• The treatment of moral responsibility as a fundamentally collective matter. The supposed virtues and sins of a nation or people are ascribed to all of its individual members, so that, for example, one speaks of "the Jew" (meaning all Jews collectively and each Jewish person individually) being responsible for the decadence of modern culture.

Anyone who reads widely in the collected works of professor Churchill, and especially anyone who listens to his speeches, will, if they are not blinded by certain ideological commitments, recognize the essentially fascist tendency of his work. If a white American were to speak of any foreign people or nation in anything like the way Churchill discusses America and Americans, the fascist character of his work would be obvious to everyone.
This point is only underlined by the behavior of Churchill's supporters, who, while not actually wearing brown shirts, did a quite convincing impersonation of fascist thugs at Thursday's meeting of the University of Colorado Regents.

All this was merely par for the course for Churchill, who believes that a Columbus Day parade is an incitement to genocide, and therefore something that he and his followers have a legal right to disrupt.

But while the question of whether a brilliant scholar with a fascist streak ought to be considered for a place on a university faculty retains at least some academic interest, it has nothing to do with Churchill, whose writings and speeches feature an incoherent farrago of boundless paranoia, wildly implausible theories, obscene celebrations of murder, and atrocious prose.

The question of whether a serious research university ought to hire someone like Churchill is laughable on its face. What's not so funny is the question of exactly how someone like him got hired in the first place, and then tenured and named the head of a department.

That, in the end, is a more important question than what will or ought to happen to Churchill now. Churchill is a pathetic buffoon, but the University of Colorado is far from alone in having allowed itself to toss intellectual integrity and human decency overboard in the pursuit of worthy goals.

Speaking truth to power, giving a voice to those who have been silenced, pursuing controversial and unpopular ideas in an intellectually rigorous way - these are all things that the university in general, and this university in particular, has done and continues to do.

That through whatever combination of negligence, cowardice and complicity we have allowed Ward Churchill to besmirch those ideals by invoking them in the defense of his contemptible rantings is now our burden and our shame.

Paul Campos is a professor of law at the University of Colorado. He can be reached at .

Friday, February 04, 2005

Victory at Cal State-Long Beach


A victory in the fight against leftist indoctronation and intolerance on one college campus. Marissa, this Sailor salutes you for taking a stand and sticking to it! - Sailor


Victory at Cal State-Long Beach

By Marissa Freimanis
FrontPageMagazine.com February 4, 2005

It is the start of a new semester at California State University-Long Beach, and the victories from the battles fought last semester in the name of Academic Freedom are finally becoming evident. Thanks to Students for Academic Freedom and FrontPage Magazine, one professor is no longer forcing his students to imitate his far-Left views -- or fail.

Last semester I was enrolled in English 100, Dr. Clifton Snider’s composition class, to fulfill my “General Education” requirement courses. (These are courses the university deems mandatory for every student to take in order to graduate.) When Dr. Snider handed out his course syllabus in the first class, I quickly thumbed through it, trying to find out basic information about the class. Instead, I found a document that seemed more relevant to a Political Science class.

The first paragraph of the syllabus states that the professor’s goal for the course was to "promote tolerance and open-mindedness" through "the open discussion of controversial issues." However, instead of any attempt to be "open-minded," the syllabus was entirely stacked in favor of Dr. Snider’s leftist ideologies.

Perhaps the most shocking segments of Dr. Snider’s syllabus can be found under the "argument topics" section. The purpose of the argument paper is “to persuade or to at least create tolerance for your point of view on a controversial issue." The following are a few examples of the "suggested" topics that Dr. Snider has listed to help us out:

"Should Justice Sandra Day O’Connor be impeached for her partisan political actions in the Bush v. Gore case?

"It is no secret that the Bush administration and many Republicans have taken steps to undo the progress in environmental protection made before they took office. Now that they control the presidency and the Congress, they have better opportunities to carry out their agenda. Narrow this topic to a particular issue that you can argue in your paper (e.g. oil drilling in Alaska, building roads on formerly protected Federal lands, and logging)

"Breaking a campaign promise, Bush has reversed rules to limit industrial carbon dioxide emissions into the atmosphere

"Civil Liberties: The Bush administration has used the terrorist attacks of 11 September 2001 to erode the civil rights of citizens and non-citizens alike; for example, it got Congress to pass the so-called "Patriot Act," which allows the government "to seize the records of bookstores and libraries to find out what people have been reading" Personal computers can also be seized by the federal government. What can be done to stop this erosion of liberties or can you logically defend it?

"What evidence do we have that Mr. Bush and his cronies lied to the American people and the world in promoting the war with Iraq? Do you agree that America has lost its "moral authority" in the world because of this immoral war?

"Energy: (nuclear, solar, fossil, synthetic fuels, etc.). A related topic is Dick Cheney's secret conference on energy policy. Why hasn't the administration revealed who participated and should it reveal this information? Also important is the fact that, as Kevin Phillips writes, "four generations of the [Bush] dynasty have chased [oil] profits through cozy ties with Mideast leaders, spinning webs of conflicts of interest"

"Birth Control: Should the so-called "morning-after" contraceptive pills (pills that prevent fertilized eggs from implantation) be more readily available to all, whether they can afford them or not and regardless of age? (You cannot argue that such pills amount to an abortion.)"

Along with his list of "suggested topics," Dr. Snider also included a list of topics that he forbade his students to write abou,t because they are "topics on which there is, in my opinion, no other side apart from chauvinistic, religious, or bigoted opinions and pseudo-science." I was absolutely outraged when I read the "topics to avoid." This list includes: Abortion, religion, same sex marriage, and prayer in public schools. These are all issues that have two reasonable points of view, yet this professor's bigotry suppressed every view but his own. That's hardly "open discussion."

I was spurred by his list and transparent intellectual discrimination to take action. Initially, I was unsure that anything I did would make a difference and justifiably worried that my attempts to expose Dr. Snider would backfire. I I feared I would have nothing to show for it but a failing grade. However, after submitting a complaint to Students for Academic Freedom, I unknowingly started a ball rolling that would eventually frustrate Dr. Snider’s desire to politicize his classroom. I told my story on FrontPageMag.com, and the rest is history. My story immediately garnered attention from columnist Mike Adams and FOX News, which aired the academic abuses of Dr. Snider nationwide. Excerpts from Dr. Snider’s class syllabus became known nationwide. Dr. Snider became the topic of discussion on numerous radio talk shows and internet forums that reached numerous citizens who otherwise would never have known the extent of academic bias on college campuses today.
The wave of negative publicity that followed forced Dr. Snider to change. He eventually made public several of his extremist statements (such as comparing President Bush to Saddam Hussein) and also removed blatantly political material -- not just from his syllabus -- but from his university website. Future students will no longer be subject to Dr. Snider’s venomous attacks or subjected to his far-Left views, much less will they have to parrot them to graduate a required university course. Perhaps for the first time in Dr. Snider’s career, his students will actually receive an education instead of an indoctrination.

The lesson learned from this situation is: Always stand up for what you think is right, and don't be afraid to fight for it! Stand up against professors who force their views upon their students and demand their students, in violation of their own conscience, endorse left-wing orthodoxy. With the strength of an organization like Students for Academic Freedom and a media outlet like FrontPage Magazine in your corner, cowardly professors like Dr. Snider don’t stand a chance.

Marissa Freimanis is a student at California State University Long Beach.

THE LEFT'S LOAN LIE

Donald Luskin takes on Paul Krugman's usual bullshit. - Sailor




Poor and Stupid.com

THE LEFT'S LOAN LIE

Can it really be that leftist economists don't know the difference between a margin account and an opportunity cost? It's basic economics. But for Paul Krugman and his acolytes and fellow travelers, it's really all about basic partisan politics.

According to Krugman's New York Times column today, when you divert some of your Social Security payroll tax dollars into a personal account of the kind that President Bush is proposing, the government is effectively making a loan to you so that you can buy stocks on margin -- "speculation that no financial adviser would recommend."

Huh? Excuse me Professor Krugman, but that's my money we're talking about -- my payroll tax dollars. My personal account. Nobody's loaning me anything.

Here's Krugman's tortured and deceptive logic that gets him to his "loan" characterization. He quotes a White House press briefing that explains how workers who opt for personal accounts would have to forgo some of their regular Social Security benefits:

"In return for the opportunity to get the benefits from the personal account, the person forgoes a certain amount of benefits from the traditional system. Now, the way that election is structured, the person comes out ahead if their personal account exceeds a 3 percent rate of return" -- after inflation -- "which is the rate of return that the trust fund bonds receive. So, basically, the net effect on an individual's benefits would be zero if his personal account earned a 3 percent rate of return."

That's perfectly fair -- it's a simple trade-off. If it didn't work that way, then workers who elected personal accounts would be double dipping. But here's the way Krugman twists it:

Translation: If you put part of your payroll taxes into a personal account, your future benefits will be reduced by an amount equivalent to the amount you would have had to repay if you had borrowed the money at a real interest rate of 3 percent.Peter Orszag of the Brookings Institution got it exactly right: "It's not a nest egg. It's a loan."

Wrong, wrong, wrong. If it's a loan at all, it's a loan you make to yourself. And that's no loan at all. Real economists -- as opposed to Democratic apparatchiks like Krugman and Orszag -- call such a thing not a loan, but an "opportunity cost."

Here's an example. Suppose you have $1000 in a money market fund earning 3%, and you are considering investing that money in the stock market. The opportunity cost of that investment will be 3%, because you give up the 3% yield of the money market fund. That means you'll only come out net ahead on the stock investment if it returns more than 3% -- just as in proposed Social Security personal accounts. But there's no loan involved here. None.

In this case, your future benefits are analogous to the money market fund. In order to invest in stocks in your personal accounts, you have to give up the future benefits. A simple trade-off. An opportunity cost. Not a loan.
Here's what a real loan would look. You have that $1000 in the money market fund, but you want to invest $2000 in the stock market. So you borrow an additional $1000 from your stockbroker.

Or in the case of Social Security, suppose you are a struggling young African American working for minimum wage. You urgently want to own stocks, so you can start building a nest egg for your family. But you have no money to invest, because Social Security taxes have sucked up anything you could have set aside from your small earnings. So you manage to borrow some money, and you invest it in stocks. That's a loan. That's speculation. And that's what the opponents of personal accounts would prefer for America.

As a side note, that quote from Peter Orszag comes from a Washington Post story yesterday by liberal Washington reporter Jonathon Weisman. His story, based on that same press briefing that Krugman quoted, completely misstated the way Social Security benefits would be offset for personal account holders. He called it a "clawback," in which the government would confiscate earnings in your personal account below 3%. An array of spokesmen both liberal and conservative -- no doubt caught by surprise by Weisman's revelation of the non-existent "clawback" -- were quoted about how shocked and dismayed they were by it. Weisman loves to quote conservatives criticizing Bush; it's his specialty.

But, of course, it was all simply wrong. After the White House issued a statement noting the error, the Post published a substantially corrected version on its web site. One can only imagine how Krugman's column today -- which quoted the Post story, and I have no doubt originally quoted it more extensively -- had to be re-engineered at the last minute before deadline, in order to avoid more than the usual embarrassment that attends the typical Krugman column.

To give you some idea of how the left respects the truth in these matters, visit the blog of U. C. Berkeley professor Brad DeLong -- a Krugman acolyte and former Clinton administration official who once described himself as "more inclined toward 'Marxism' than anybody else on the Berkeley campus," which is saying quite a bit. When the Post story first came out, he applauded Weisman and delightedly dilated on the notion of the benefit trade-off as a loan. When the correction was issued, DeLong amended his posting to say "the Post has buckled... Glad to see such spine." You'd think he'd be glad to see the truth. But no.

Update... A reader points out the the Orszag quote cited by Krugman was removed from the corrected Post story! The Times' new motto: "all the news that others find unfit to print."

Posted by Donald Luskin at 3:12 AM

Congrats to my BlogMom


Congrats to my BlogMom, Indigo, at Indigo Insights
on the occassion of her third anniversary blogging! Do click on her link and come to appreciate her wit and wisdom as I have.

This is the woman who cajoled, encourged, supported and at times threatened to kick this sailor's arse to blog. She also corrects my spelling and grammer, usually after the fact.


Happy Annivesary mom.


This sailor loves you!

Saddam Hussein and Abu Nidal, Terrorist Allies


While the left continues to make believe that saddam had no ties to terrorists, Thomas Joscelyn, points out some interesting connections saddam did have to terrorists that might have helped saddam launch attacks on the US and US interests abroad. He also helps to debunk that whole "blood for oil" mantra - Sailor




Saddam Hussein and Abu Nidal, Terrorist Allies
By Thomas Joscelyn
FrontPageMagazine.com February 4, 2005

In a recent Frontpage Interview with Edwin Black, author of several books, interviewer Jamie Glazov correctly pointed out that “there is substantial evidence of [Saddam] Hussein's associations with world terrorism before we invaded Iraq. The Iraqi dictator aided, abetted, and provided sanctuary to Abu Nidal's terrorists, Abu Abbas, and all kinds of radical Islamic terrorist groups – Hizbollah and Hamas among them.”

Saddam’s relationship with Abu Nidal (the nom de guerre of Palestinian terrorist Sabri al-Bana) deserves special scrutiny since, as many intelligence analysts and commentators have noted, he was “the bin Laden of the 1970s and 1980s.” That is, at that time he was the most lethal and feared terrorist in the world.

In response, Mr. Black first commented, “Let's get the facts in focus. I followed the career of Abu Nidal …,” and then briefly recounted Abu Nidal’s career. In his brief synopsis of Nidal’s terrorist resume, which spanned several decades, Mr. Black downplayed the relationship between Abu Nidal’s terrorist organization (ANO) and Saddam’s regime in recent years. His retelling skipped over at least several pertinent facts.

Mr. Black’s version of events leaves the audience with the impression that between the time of the first Gulf War in 1991, when the Kuwaitis apparently purchased Nidal’s services, and 2002, when Nidal died of unnatural causes in Iraq, there was no relationship between Nidal and Saddam. Mr. Black summarized Nidal’s involvement with the Kuwaitis during the Gulf War when he said, “[T]he money-hungry Abu Nidal conspired with the Kuwaiti authorities against his former host in Kuwait's conflict with Saddam. He provided intelligence against Iraq to the Kuwaitis to be transmitted to the Americans during the first Gulf War.” The next stage in the relationship between Saddam’s regime and Nidal after their Gulf War schism, according to Mr. Black’s interview, comes in 2002, when “Abu Nidal was admitted into Iraq and either immediately murdered by Saddam's intelligence operatives, or somehow convinced to commit suicide by shooting his brains out.”

There are several problems with this brief review.

Notably absent from Mr. Black’s telling is any memory of the events of late 1998. With both parties under extreme duress – Nidal had lost his refuge in Egypt and Saddam faced mounting international pressure from the U.N. as well as a bombing campaign by the U.S. and U.K. in December – the two apparently reconciled. The State Department’s 1998 Patterns of Global Terrorism report described the renewed relationship: “[I]n December [1998] press reports indicated that Abu Nidal had relocated to Iraq and may be receiving medical treatment. Abu Nidal's move to Baghdad – if true – would increase the prospect that Saddam may call on the ANO to conduct anti-US attacks.” Thus, in response to renewed military intervention and diplomatic pressure from the West, Saddam sought to rekindle his relationship with an old terrorist ally. The State Department’s Patterns of Global Terrorism reports in the following years similarly cited Saddam’s cooperation with the ANO and his willingness to provide refuge for its members.

The press reports mentioned in the State Department’s 1998 Patterns of Global Terrorism actually continued into the New Year. For example, The New York Times reported on the renewed relationship on January 27, 1999. In a story aptly titled “A Much-Shunned Terrorist Is Said to Find Haven in Iraq,” The Times reported that Nidal had made his way to Baghdad about ten days prior to the U.S.-led bombing campaign on December 16, 1998. The Times further warned:

“Abu Nidal, one of the world's most infamous terrorists, moved to Baghdad late last year and obtained the protection of President Saddam Hussein, according to intelligence reports received by United States and Middle Eastern government officials. The reports have raised questions about whether Iraq is pushing to establish a terrorism network, American and Middle Eastern officials say. … Abu Nidal's move to Iraq, which he was forced to leave 15 years ago because of his ties to Syria, suggests that he may have renewed a relationship with President Hussein. ‘He could become a more significant threat again if he finds more effective state sponsorship,’ an American intelligence official said.”

The timing of Saddam’s renewed relationship with Nidal was conspicuous for at least several reasons. First, as mentioned above, Nidal relocated to Baghdad at the height of tensions between the U.S. and Saddam’s regime. Between the first and second Gulf Wars there was, arguably, no more stressful time in the ongoing feud between Iraq and the West than in December 1998. Did Saddam plan to enlist Nidal’s support in a new round of terrorist strikes against the West? Did Saddam plan to use terrorism in retaliation for the Operation Desert Fox bombing campaign and continued sanctions?

Second, we know that at the time of Nidal’s relocation to Baghdad Saddam’s regime was planning at least one terrorist strike against an American target. In December 1998 the Iraqi consul in Prague, Jabir Salim, defected and revealed to British intelligence that he had been charged with hiring terrorists to blow up America’s Radio Free Europe building in Prague. The bombing was most likely intended as retaliation for President Clinton’s signing of the Iraqi Liberation Act, which authorized the creation of Radio Free Iraq. Radio Free Iraq began broadcasting anti-regime messages from the Radio Free Europe building in Prague into Iraq late in 1998. (Edward Jay Epstein has reported on this bomb plot. See, for example, http://www.edwardjayepstein.com/ClarkesIraq.htm)

Third, and most importantly, in December 1998 countless media outlets around the world began to report Saddam’s outreach to another arch-terrorist, Osama bin Laden. Saddam sent one of his top intelligence operatives, Faruq Hijazi, to visit bin Laden and his cohorts in Afghanistan on December 21 (just two days after Operation Desert Fox ended). Reports of this meeting set off a flurry of media reports throughout the world. The first account in Milan’s Corriere Della Sera (December 28) was followed by reports in the Paris-based Al-Watan Al-Arabi, Newsweek, ABC News, the New York Post, the London Guardian, several Arab newspapers and even Radio Free Iraq. (Side note: The 9/11 Commission was either unaware or ignored all of these reports, as they are not even mentioned in the Commission’s much-heralded report.)

There remains a distinct possiblity that Saddam’s contacts with Nidal and bin Laden were part of his grand strategy to launch a series of terrorist strikes against the U.S. For instance, the New York Post’s account at the time (Niles Lathem, “Saddam’s New Weapon: Terror; Courting Bin Laden & Nidal: U.S.,” February 1, 1999) explicity warned:

“Saddam Hussein – battered, humiliated and increasingly isolated – plans to resort to terrorism in revenge for U.S. airstrikes against his country, the Clinton administration believes. … U.S. officials say the CIA has received ‘credible and reliable’ intelligence reports that Saddam is forging alliances with some of the Middle East's most bloodthirsty terrorists – including Osama Bin Laden and Abu Nidal – as part of an apparently new campaign to strike American targets and possibly destabilize Saudi Arabia and Kuwait.”

Was Saddam planning a new terrorist offensive againt the U.S.? Much of the evidence indicates that he was. However, much of the story – including the details of Nidal’s renewed relationship with Saddam – remains a mystery. For example, did Nidal stay in Iraq from December 1998 till his death in 2002? If so, what did Saddam expect him to do? (Nidal certainly was not invited to stay in Iraq without a quid pro quo.)

Perhaps the most interesting mystery surrounds Nidal’s death. In his interview with FrontPageMag.com, Mr. Black said of Nidal’s death, “In August 2002, Abu Nidal was admitted into Iraq and either immediately murdered by Saddam's intelligence operatives, or somehow convinced to commit suicide by shooting his brains out.” But, as discussed above, Nidal was readmitted into Iraq in December 1998 and some reports say he was shot in the head several times, which would make the possibility of suicide highly unlikely.

The real question surrounding Nidal’s death is why he was killed. The reasons offered by Palestinian and other sources vary. Some say he committed suicide to escape his suffering from leukemia (unlikely, for the reason given above) while others say that he was assassinated by Saddam’s regime for attempting to plan a coup at the behest of one of the Gulf states (which is possible but, again, unlikely). A more probable reason for Nidal’s assassination is that he knew too much about Saddam’s terrorist ties and, with the possibility of an approaching war, that was a liability Saddam could not afford.

While many uncertainties surrounding Saddam’s terrorist aspirations remain, it is clear that Saddam was a vital sponsor of various terrorist groups and had ties to some of the most lethal terrorists in history. It is also clear that the justifications for the war go far beyond Mr. Black’s assertion that “Iraq came to the top of the list because of our strategic interest. That strategic interest is oil.”
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thomas Joscelyn is an economist who works on antitrust and security issues.